Does David Childs deserve to be called (amongst other things) a sycophant, a liar, a hypocrite, a freeloader?
liar and hypocrite, yes, judging from the promotional material i have seen.
Does Duncan deserve to have his ability as a player, called into question?
not on this thread, unless it turned out he could only play on york instruments with full service history.
I'll let you decide, but maybe the answer is why its 'open season' on Baritastic.
aren't there site rules against this sort of bullying? if he has done something wrong, why not discipline him rather than encouraging others to join you?