Which old test piece would you like to see revived

Favourite revival piece

  • Triumphant Rhapsody

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Connotations

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • The Frogs of Aristophanes

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Volcano

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Pageantry

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Kensington Concerto

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Other

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    62

Dave Payn

Active Member
This was inspired, oddly enough, by one of the posts disagreeing with my 'French horn' ideas! It was a valid point declaring concern that a legacy of wonderful brass band music might be lost if French horns were a permanent fixture in bands (something I wouldn't advocate).

So on the legacy point, which old nationals test piece test piece (let's say pre 1980) would you like to see revived at the National championships in the future? I've polled a list but with an 'other' option.

I go for Checkmate. Sufficiently tricky enough even by todays standards (IMHO) and to my ears, one of the very best examples of a brass band arrangement sounding like it could have been written with a brass band in mind.

What's your favourite?
 

Accidental

Supporting Member
Good thread - again! (Do you do any work Dave, or sit there all day thinking up cool stuff to put on here?!! :wink: :lol: )

I'm not convinced some of these ever really went away though - Journey, The Frogs and Kensington have all been 1st section finals pieces in the last 10 years. (hey what a boc am I! :oops: ) I've voted for Connotations because I love it and would quite happily sit and listen to 15+ decent bands playing it. Its the only piece on the list I've only got one recording of too - not sure if that means anything or not!
 

Dave Payn

Active Member
Accidental said:
Good thread - again! (Do you do any work Dave, or sit there all day thinking up cool stuff to put on here?!! :wink: :lol: )

Moi? My particular line of work is (honest!) relatively quiet at present but believe me, from next month onwards you won't see much of me! (What do you mean, 'hurrah'!)


I'm not convinced some of these ever really went away though - Journey, The Frogs and Kensington have all been 1st section finals pieces in the last 10 years. (hey what a boc am I! :oops: ) I've voted for Connotations because I love it and would quite happily sit and listen to 15+ decent bands playing it. Its the only piece on the list I've only got one recording of too - not sure if that means anything or not!
You mean you haven't got any other recordings of anything? :lol:

Sorry, I should have said, I would like these (even if some championship based players think they're too easy nowadays) to be revived for an Albert Hall appearance!
 

Dave Payn

Active Member
Accidental said:
Good thread - again! (Do you do any work Dave, or sit there all day thinking up cool stuff to put on here?!! :wink: :lol: )
AND..... There's a copyright forum here so some of the stuff I post on here is actually work related........... (liar, liar, pants. etc.)
 

MRSH

Supporting Member
Of the test pieces named I would go for Le Roi d'Ys. Good solos, good tunes and good technique needed - and expertly arranged.

However, I voted 'other' and I'm gonna go just outside to 1981 and say Blitz. I love it. One of Bourgeois's(!) best ever and not played as often as it deserves to be. IMHO.

Matt
 

Accidental

Supporting Member
:lol: :lol:

We've got about 200 band cds and not much else. Sad but true!

As far as "too easy" goes, I think it makes a pleasant change when the pieces are less technically demanding and the bands have to work hard at the music to stand out. Maunsell Forts is a pretty good recent example. For the Albert Hall I think I'd stick with Connotations, or maybe Roi D'Ys to see how this "generation" of euphs do.

(But if Blitz had been on the poll, I would've voted for that :wink: )
 

johnflugel

Active Member
It's not that old, but would like to hear 'Spectrum' aired by a number of bands. 'Moorside Suite' would still be a good test for higher section bands I believe.

Also, if you are a 3rd/4th section band after a good test work, look no further than Morley Calverts 'Canadian Folk Song Suite'. Those at the RNCM on Saturday heard Fodens perform what I think could be an excellent, fun, listenable and sufficiently testing work for the lower sections. Also, Eric Ball's 'Air Varie-The Old Wells' which was commended by Elgar after seeing the score back in the early part of the last century.

John
 

bassinthebathroom

Active Member
Put my cross next to Triumphant Rhapsody, a piece that I remember playing on my first Cornwall Youth Band course, some time ago! It's a great piece, that sadly doesn't see much light nowadays. It was a little cruel to make me choose though! :?
 

PeterBale

Moderator
Staff member
I've voted "other" as I would go for Eric Cundell's "Blackfriars". I'd not heard it before I was sent the Virtuosi Brass band cds to review. I have to agree with the writer of the sleeve notes that it is a very attractive piece which would still provide a challenge for any band, and it seems to have been unduly neglected over the years.
 

missflugel

Member
The top section at the Durham League Contest are playing Triumphant Rhapsody and last year the piece was Journey in to Freedom.

Perhaps its up to more local contests to play such pieces as suggested in the poll so they can be recognised once again by newer band contest audiences
 

The Cornet King

Active Member
I would love to see Life Divine by Cyril Jenkins used again.
Great piece and still could be a pretty tough test for bands of today. Hard piece, easy on the ear of the audience and bandsmen /women alike. Great piece. :D

I know the thought of starting the piece on a Top C would scare me a bit! :D
 
I actually voted for 'Journey into Freedom', mainly because I enjoy listening to it!!!

However, I must also echo johnflugel's comments regarding 'The Old Wells' & 'Canadian Folk Song Suite'. Both are great to listen to, and provide a good test of players as well.

johnflugel said:
Also, if you are a 3rd/4th section band after a good test work, look no further than Morley Calverts 'Canadian Folk Song Suite'. Those at the RNCM on Saturday heard Fodens perform what I think could be an excellent, fun, listenable and sufficiently testing work for the lower sections. Also, Eric Ball's 'Air Varie-The Old Wells' which was commended by Elgar after seeing the score back in the early part of the last century.
Simon Rowney
 

johnflugel

Active Member
Chippy_Cornet said:
I actually voted for 'Journey into Freedom', mainly because I enjoy listening to it!!!
Well Chippy, if I can call you that :) , if you can get a day off from wife and child, you could visit Blackpool in May when it will be the test piece for the Senior Cup.

I forgot to say, I voted for Volcano. Top piece, I like some of Robert Simpsons music...anybody played Energy...it's rock hard.

John
 

Naomi McFadyen

New Member
I went for "other" purely because I can...

:p

erm, and I'm sure I'll think of a really good old piece that hasnt been used in years... Labour and Love or something... I dunno

:)
 

eckyboy

Member
Le Roi d'Ys is a classic I've not played for years but is Plantagenates no thought of anymore.Still my alltime fave.
Do the rest of tmps not like it
 
ermmmmmm ......Pagentry, High Peak, and Connotations, there are so many great pieces that should be given light of day on the stand.
It does seem that the league contests appear to giving them a revival, especially in Durham, lead the way I say!
 

Okiedokie of Oz

Active Member
I played Le roi d'Ys for the first time back in 2001 and found it to be one of the best test pieces I'd played, along with a lot of Philip Sparke's stuff and a few special ones. I encourage bands to play it more!
 

WhatSharp?

Active Member
I'd go along with Life Divine, and also throw in Shining River (1st Section?).

Devil and the Deep Blue Sea? (when was this last played?)
Land of the Long White Cloud (1st?)
 
Top