Accidental
Supporting Member
**BOC ALERT**
One of our cornets is very familiar with the recorded version of this (YBS Hymn of the Highlands) and has spotted that in bar 30, Stuart Lingard plays G-G-F-D but the printed part has G-G-D-B. Being a big YBS fan he's adamant its a misprint in the published version, but the guy playing the solo insists its right in terms of chord structure etc. :roll:
The million dollar questions are...... Why? and which one is right?
Possible explanations so far are:
1 it was recorded off manuscript and then misprinted at publication
2 either SL or DK changed it because they thought it sounded better
3 SL just played it wrong (unlikely!) and DK didn't notice (impossible?!!)
PLEASE could someone (Aidan??) settle the argument before we get fisticuffs in the middle of band practice and need to advertise for 2 new solo cornets! :lol:
One of our cornets is very familiar with the recorded version of this (YBS Hymn of the Highlands) and has spotted that in bar 30, Stuart Lingard plays G-G-F-D but the printed part has G-G-D-B. Being a big YBS fan he's adamant its a misprint in the published version, but the guy playing the solo insists its right in terms of chord structure etc. :roll:
The million dollar questions are...... Why? and which one is right?
Possible explanations so far are:
1 it was recorded off manuscript and then misprinted at publication
2 either SL or DK changed it because they thought it sounded better
3 SL just played it wrong (unlikely!) and DK didn't notice (impossible?!!)
PLEASE could someone (Aidan??) settle the argument before we get fisticuffs in the middle of band practice and need to advertise for 2 new solo cornets! :lol: