Errata sheet for Comedy Overture?

Has anyone found problems in any of the parts? We're findingthat not all of the individual parts correspond with the score and with other parts around the band?
Is anyone else having problems with this and is there a known errata sheet?
Look forward to your responses.
Regards
James
Jackfield Elcock Reisen Band
 

AndyCat

Active Member
I brought this up with a member of the Test Piece Selection panel 2 weeks ago, so the problem has been raised with them.

Slightly difficult one though, as John Ireland is unavailable at present!
 
Great Andy, could you keep us posted of any respons?
Also if anyone finds any errors so could post them up here so that we can all check them out!
We should moan though as it's only been about about since 1934 and that isn't any time to eradicate any problemos!
James
 

AndyCat

Active Member
jimmythesaint said:
Great Andy, could you keep us posted of any respons?
Also if anyone finds any errors so could post them up here so that we can all check them out!
We should moan though as it's only been about about since 1934 and that isn't any time to eradicate any problemos!
James

Unfortunately, that's what will stop them doing one if anything does I would think.

The fact that it has been used, performed and recorded so many times without anyone asking for an errata may stop them investing time and money, in such a short space of time, in producing one.
 

PeterBale

Moderator
Staff member
jimmythesaint said:
Great Andy, could you keep us posted of any respons?
Also if anyone finds any errors so could post them up here so that we can all check them out!
We should moan though as it's only been about about since 1934 and that isn't any time to eradicate any problemos!
James
Believe it or not, only a few weks ago I picked up an error in the BBb* bass part of Eric Balls "King of Kings" (triplet mark missing) :shock:
Edit: Sorry, EEb bass part, bar before"I" :shock:

Must have been played hundreds of times, and either nobody had spotted it or they'd just gone along with what everyone else was playing, whereas for me, sight-reading it, I read it as written, & wondered why it was adrift :D
 
Last edited:

Griffin

Active Member
I know somewhere (thinks its around '24') that the Bass Trombone has 5 bars rest written, but they aren't! Ignore it.

Ask Timbloke, he'll know for sure.
 

Owen S

Member
In the 2nd cornet part, there is a crotchet rest missing somewhere on the bottom line of the first page. We spotted it because we had too few notes in the bar. Much like many of the errors, I seem to remember this can be solved by comparison to the score.

We have found quite a few other errors, I'm sure. That said, by far the most common error seems to be consistency of crescendos and diminuendos, both in their presence or absence, and in the positioning of their starts and ends.
 

Dave Payn

Active Member
jimmythesaint said:
Has anyone found problems in any of the parts? We're findingthat not all of the individual parts correspond with the score and with other parts around the band?
Is anyone else having problems with this and is there a known errata sheet?
Look forward to your responses.
Regards
James
Jackfield Elcock Reisen Band

Occasions like this are the banding equivalent of Groundhog Day........ you wake up, it's major contest rehearsal time again and....yup, discrepanices between score and parts!
 
hate it when this happens,
With a contest like the area, the publishers release a new score and set of parts for the bands and make a fortune. However it always seem that whoever checks the score and parts before publishing it always seem to have his eyes closed.
Remember all the errors in Coventry last year!

from what we have noticed, there is loads of discrepencies in the dynamics on the parts being different to those on the score
 

GJG

Well-Known Member
ScreamingSop said:
hate it when this happens,
With a contest like the area, the publishers release a new score and set of parts for the bands and make a fortune. However it always seem that whoever checks the score and parts before publishing it always seem to have his eyes closed.
Remember all the errors in Coventry last year!

from what we have noticed, there is loads of discrepencies in the dynamics on the parts being different to those on the score
Having spoken to the publishers specifically on this point, it seems there is no "new version" of "Comedy" as such. All they have done is to scan the original engraved score and parts (making no attempt to edit in any way - there is no real way of doing this without re-originating the score from scratch using Finale/Sibelius/whatever) and created new laser-printed sets, which are scaled to fit A4/A3 paper size. This, along with the fact that they are printing on nice clean white paper as opposed to buff "Octavo" (or whatever) size, seems to have misled some people into thinking they were buying a "new version". Consequently, there is no issue of proof-reading, unless you want to criticise the original proofing in 1934, that is.

G.
 

Griffin

Active Member
We found a howler yesterday... Cant remeber where it is though!
Its about half way through, The front row cornets have an F#, but every one else has an F or C natural, it should be Sharp.

I'll let you know for definate, when I know. (Sop is resting, so not sure!)
 

Laserbeam bass

Active Member
I think that the rain forests in Brazil would be totally decimated if they were to produce an errata sheet(s) on Comedy Overture. In the BBb bass part this is what I have found so far

Bar 1 given Dynamic on part mp, in score mf.
Bar 6 Bottom G should be a quaver not a crotchet
Bar before 1 decrescendo missing
At Figure 1 C and Cb should be staccato
Bar before figure 4 second quaver should be a Cb
9th Bar of figure 5 D crotchet should be an F
3rd Bar of figure 8 crescendo missing
Bar before figure 20 is one only and it would appear that this is the case for the remainder of the piece WTF? tutti in the EEb part marked at 22
2 bars before 24 the bottom D should not be marked staccato, it is a speck of dirt on the template LOL

Will check back after we have gone through it completely
 

timbloke

Member
Griffin said:
We found a howler yesterday... Cant remeber where it is though!
Its about half way through, The front row cornets have an F#, but every one else has an F or C natural, it should be Sharp.

I'll let you know for definate, when I know. (Sop is resting, so not sure!)

Its' the last note two bars before 30.

Loads of missing dynamics in the solo tromb part.

either 35 or 34 in the wrong place on 2nd cornet, 27 in the wrong place on 3rd cornet.

it is amazingly frustrating when you get shouted at for not playing the right dynamics, when you are playing the right dynamics.
 

Owen S

Member
timbloke said:
Its' the last note two bars before 30.

Loads of missing dynamics in the solo tromb part.

either 35 or 34 in the wrong place on 2nd cornet, 27 in the wrong place on 3rd cornet.

it is amazingly frustrating when you get shouted at for not playing the right dynamics, when you are playing the right dynamics.
To make it clear:

2nd cornet: 34 should be a bar earlier than written
3rd cornet: 27 should be a bar earlier than written

There are several other problems like this around the band
 

Product tMP members are discussing

Top