Page 4 of 4 FirstFirst 1 2 3 4
Results 46 to 56 of 56

Thread: Area Appeals

  1. #46
    Previously known as "Essex Elvis" Red Elvis's Avatar
    Join Date
    26.07.2004
    Location
    London
    Posts
    1,035
    Quote Originally Posted by Pauli Walnuts View Post
    I am intrigued as to which contest featured the mop and bucket - can you share more on that one one Will?
    If memory serves , it was Butlins 2007 , 1st section ,and the band concerned were Ipswich and Norwich Co-op (some months before I joined them - I was still with Becontree at the time) and so it wouldn't have any impact on gradings. From what I gather , the band were offered the option of going on again last and playing again - as far as I know they decided to let it stand as was. Becontree came bottom of the section that year without the aid of interruptions from cleaners or fire alarms !!
    "Then raise the scarlet banner high , beneath its folds we'll live and die.Though cowards flinch and traitors sneer we'll keep the Red Flag flying here"
    Phil
    TMP Political Commissar
    EEb Bass
    Clacton Co-Op Band

  2. #47
    tMP Posting Freak!!! MoominDave's Avatar
    Join Date
    29.03.2003
    Location
    Oxford
    Posts
    5,767
    Quote Originally Posted by stevetrom View Post
    No big deal being relegated - if you're good enough you can bounce straight back up.
    Not really how it works - look at Scotland for an example, where the top two are promoted each year and relegation is done on a weighted aggregate (but still one that works more quickly than the English/Welsh system). Bands move through the sections much more freely, and consequently more players tend to be less long-term loyal to bands. A band that is relegated while holding a number of talented players whose commitment is dependent on playing for an x-section band is likely to stay relegated. In fact, I could cite a number of cases where more than one relegation has happened to a band in close succession in Scotland. Lochgelly is one good example - a band that's been to both bottom and top in the last 20 years - but it's not the only one.

    IMO, the Scottish system moves bands around too fast, whereas the English/Welsh system doesn't move them around quickly enough. Your proposal would be even faster than the Scottish system.
    Dave Taylor
    Bass Trombone
    Kidlington

  3. #48
    tMP Prime Friend stevetrom's Avatar
    Join Date
    19.03.2003
    Location
    Oxfordshire
    Posts
    1,760
    Quote Originally Posted by MoominDave View Post
    ...IMO, the Scottish system moves bands around too fast, whereas the English/Welsh system doesn't move them around quickly enough. Your proposal would be even faster than the Scottish system.
    you didn't expect me to do any research, or even think for very long, before offering my opinion did you?
    Where's the fun in that?

    I agree that the current system in England is way to slow and, when combined with some stupidly large sections, bands )like mine) can get stuck in the middle of a section never to go up or down.

    If players leave a band simply because it gets relegated are they really the type of characters you want in the band?
    Bass Trom, Brackley & District Band, http://www.brackleyband.org.uk/

    The last thing I want to do is hurt you. But it's still on my list.

  4. #49
    tMP Posting Freak!!! MoominDave's Avatar
    Join Date
    29.03.2003
    Location
    Oxford
    Posts
    5,767
    My point was that having a system that moves bands around too quickly encourages an atmosphere where it is seen as a more reasonable thing to move bands more often. Relegation (or promotion) can become a feedback loop under such circumstances due to this. Our system damps that feedback loop more than sufficiently - too much, in fact; the Scottish system doesn't damp it enough.
    Dave Taylor
    Bass Trombone
    Kidlington

  5. #50
    tMP Prime Friend stevetrom's Avatar
    Join Date
    19.03.2003
    Location
    Oxfordshire
    Posts
    1,760
    ok then.

    1st place automatic promotion
    Last place automatic relegation
    1 (or 2) more band promoted/relegated based on weighted average similar to Scotland
    Bass Trom, Brackley & District Band, http://www.brackleyband.org.uk/

    The last thing I want to do is hurt you. But it's still on my list.

  6. #51
    tMP Posting Freak!!! MoominDave's Avatar
    Join Date
    29.03.2003
    Location
    Oxford
    Posts
    5,767
    We won't know until we try it! But I suspect it would still be a bit fast - promotion would be a little slower than Scotland, but relegation would be a little faster.

    Incidentally, I believe the Scots have been looking at a play-off system recently.
    Dave Taylor
    Bass Trombone
    Kidlington

  7. #52
    tMP Friend yoda's Avatar
    Join Date
    19.03.2009
    Posts
    114
    Quote Originally Posted by MoominDave View Post
    Incidentally, I believe the Scots have been looking at a play-off system recently.
    At the end of the contest, the bands placed 2nd, 3rd, and 4th (in the league not the contest) would play again to secure promotion, while 3 bands making up the bottom 4(in the league) would play again to see who escapes religation, assuming the bottom one gets relegated and the top one gets promoted as of right.............

    Interesting idea.........

    not sure it would do much for the bar sales

    also, the midlands 4th section would last at least another 2 hours which everyone wants of course
    “Do or do not... there is no try"

  8. #53
    tMP Friend for Life Will the Sec's Avatar
    Join Date
    27.02.2004
    Location
    London
    Posts
    3,781
    When would the play offs take place? Allowing for the propensity for bands beng in the bottom four to have been absent from the qualifier, it would not work on the same day, and why would a band turn up on a different day just to be relegated? Especially given the distances and associated costs in some regions.
    Will Elsom

    My Score Exchange Site

    A man once accused of being able to write a melody...

    A wise man once said, "Pointing out a fallacy in someone's argument is not the same as pedantically and persistently pushing it down someone's throat whilst completely ignoring other points that are made."

  9. #54
    tMP Prime Friend Laserbeam bass's Avatar
    Join Date
    18.09.2003
    Location
    The engine room
    Posts
    2,190
    Quote Originally Posted by Will the Sec View Post
    I might compose some rubbish, Pauli, but I haven't stooped that low. Yet. ... ... ... Leaves gap for LBB to say something... ... ... Oh, hang on, there was this.
    Thanks for the nod Bro. I was intending to write a comedic piece, but as I have now been given a great idea from Pauli, I will have to reconsider.

    Quote Originally Posted by Will the Sec View Post
    Whilst the band finishing ninth was promoted. I wonder which is happier? Egham for going up or Becontree for staying down?
    Didn't want to get promoted, and don't want to win the Nationals neither. That way we can defend our Butlin's 1st section crown

    Quote Originally Posted by Red Elvis View Post
    If memory serves , it was Butlins 2007 , 1st section ,and the band concerned were Ipswich and Norwich Co-op (some months before I joined them - I was still with Becontree at the time) and so it wouldn't have any impact on gradings. From what I gather , the band were offered the option of going on again last and playing again - as far as I know they decided to let it stand as was. Becontree came bottom of the section that year without the aid of interruptions from cleaners or fire alarms !!
    I have one thing to say



    We were actually lead astray by a prominent cornet player. Drank until silly o'clock on the Saturday morning, and managed to put in a performance of such a low standard, that we actually awarded last place in the 4th Section
    Nothing to see

  10. #55
    tMP Master Friend
    Join Date
    04.07.2009
    Location
    Hayle
    Posts
    564
    I wonder if the unnamed band's successful appeal against relegation adversely affected my band's appeal for promotion?
    ----------------------
    Simon Phillips

  11. #56
    tMP Friend for Life Will the Sec's Avatar
    Join Date
    27.02.2004
    Location
    London
    Posts
    3,781
    Ah. the good old days at Becontree.
    Will Elsom

    My Score Exchange Site

    A man once accused of being able to write a melody...

    A wise man once said, "Pointing out a fallacy in someone's argument is not the same as pedantically and persistently pushing it down someone's throat whilst completely ignoring other points that are made."

Page 4 of 4 FirstFirst 1 2 3 4

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •