PDA

View Full Version : Champ/First : Forest of Dean Brass


TheMusicMan
12.05.2007, 13:34
Weston-Super-Mare – Own Choice Contest - 2007

http://www.themouthpiece.com/images/weston2007/forestofdean.jpg (http://www.themouthpiece.com/vb/../images/weston2007/chalford.jpg)




Section Entered : Championship/First
National Grading : First Section
Order of Play : 1
Musical Director : Jackie Gwynne
Chosen Test Piece : Variations on a Ninth
http://www.fodbrass.co.uk/





*************************************************
No score or music provided

Start: excellent opening, triplet semis well controlled.

Slightly down-tempo for next section... did you intend that? Moves nicely into Waltz. This section seems a tad 'harsh'... as though all the notes are attacked...!! Sorry, that's just what I hear.

Bass drum not in time...

Into slower movement.... and cadenzas:

Sop: nervous, slightly muddled
Horn: well played...
Baritone: nicely done...
Euphonium: a little tentative - but then again I couldn't do it, so who am I to comment!!!

Lovely solo cornet sound into next section, backed up by nice sop. Solo Ct cad a little blippy, but gorgeous sound. Troms a tad overblown...

Lovely Euphonium melody line.

Next Var: sounds a little slow to me and perhaps a little harsh in places - ie no roundness. Euph solo - well played. Ct solo that follows also well played... you have a cracking sound. It is very hard to comment accurately without a score to refer to, but this movement progresses very well, some nicer balanced sounds prevail.

Next Var: untidy on xyl and cts... it sounds messy and unclear...

Next Var: cornet solo, class playing sir... your sound is warm, musical and expressive. Unison cts good... Cymbal too loud on crash roll...

Next Var: very steady tempo, a little too steady for my personal liking.

Ending: very loud, but balanced.

In summary, too cluttered and untidy to find a podium placing I feel... sorry! Solo Ct might get the soloist award though!


************************************************

Di
20.05.2007, 18:00
We have offered our opinion of the bands performance based on the music, and on what we hear; and not on the technicalities of notes and other musical markings in the score etc.

Please don't be offended if you don't agree with what we write. This will simply be a combination of a report of our opinions on how we felt the performance went on the day, and of what's happening at the contest.

Please feel free to add your comments and your scores based on what you heard but please remember to keep these constructive and within the spirit of tMP and our guidelines. :)

basstromblloyd
20.05.2007, 22:00
:biggrin: i thought that this band did play well today it sounded really good a proper preformence but i only heard it from outside the doors :D so i dont no wat it was like in there lol