Discussion in 'Off-Topic Chat' started by Jack, May 10, 2009.
wats the longest note people have held on without circular breathing?
Find more discussions like this one
longest note peoplelongest note watscircular breathing
Can't say I've ever got the stopwatch out. I suppose it depends what instrument you're on doesn't it?
After all, who'll win on a long-note-contest out of a Sop player and a BBb Bass?
Eb Bass part for "Send in the clowns" starts with about 35 bars of tied-over middle Gs, but I doubt anyone ever got through them all without breathing!
28 seconds that I've actually timed! (Yes I used to time myself.. I have no life!)
I know of people who can do a fair bit longer than that though.
I give up. Was it a C#?
this reminds me of band camp...
...don't know what the exact tuning note was, but I believe Kenny G, world renowned saxophonist, holds the world record on a soprano saxophone at 45 minutes!
Was at his concert the other week in Glasgow Royal Concert Hall when he held a single note whilst walking around the audience for at least 7 minutes.
..as for me, I can't circular breathe....easier on BBb Bass with bellows fitted to your bottom!
Kenny G playing one note for 45 minutes on a soprano saxophone....
....and we say some of the stuff bands play is unlistenable...
I didn't time it, but the end of the first movement in Lowry Sketchbook has a long note for the baris (with perc tinkling away underneath), and we had to practise for weeks to be able to do nine repeats of the perc part (our MDs idea)...got to have been around 20 seconds I reckon.
Another long one is the beginning of Isiah 40....you really have to play it at the marked dynamic to last until the end of that note...scary.
Just remembered... West Ridings by, Paul Lovatt-Cooper.
Played this at the NABBC meeting a couple of weeks ago - and despite sounding like a reprise of Dark Side of the Moon, it also contained (if I remember correctly) 36 solid bars of tied over Pedal Cs for the 2nd BBb Bass.
Anyone got any bellows?
hahaha i managed a minute... but i went really dizzy wen i did...
33 seconds on an F# below the stave.
I did a whole breve once. Proper mental.
A breve isn't necessarily a long note.
A Breve at crotchet = 120 only lasts 8 seconds.
mind that sarcasm that's flying over your head :biggrin:
Proper trombonist there. Not only did you miss the sarcasm, you got the time wrong as well. It's no wonder they don't trust us with those piston things.
One of our tromboffonists (Who is incidentally also a conductor) did recently text us from a rehearsal of a band he was helping out, with the query "What does it mean when a semibreve has little lines at the side of it?"
Having suggested he ask the conductor - or alternatively actually read the time signature - we didn't hear any more.
And they say us bass players are thick!!
That made me giggle...
I'm tempted to move to baritone in the hope it'll make me appear more intelligent.
Whoops, silly me, if the crotchet was at 60 it would be 8 seconds!
I got the sarcasm. I just chose to ignore it, I do that a lot, really annoys people
Separate names with a comma.