Conducting workshop - why so little interest?

Discussion in 'The Rehearsal Room' started by Jack E, Oct 30, 2018.

  1. 2nd tenor

    2nd tenor Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    1,329
    Location:
    Chigley
    You did indeed misunderstand my last sentence.

    Encouragement does not mean pestering and shaming individuals.

    As I said in my earlier post the thread is going nowhere useful so I’m going to step back from it. As they say ‘you can take a horse to water ..........’.

    All the best, 2T.
     
  2. Euphonium Lite

    Euphonium Lite Active Member

    Messages:
    496
    Location:
    Dereham, Norfolk
    I wanted to conduct in my teenage years, and actually did an arrangement of a simple piece for our youth band on the proviso that I would be able to conduct it at the spring concert (which I did). At the time it was a bit of a flappy 2 arm mirror, I didnt have to worry about pauses and it was really only starting and stopping the band together

    When I went to Salford I took a bit more interest in what conductors actually did, but developed a style by conducting along to a tape - I had a couple of tapes of Lloyd Webber Musicals and a piano score of each set of music - again it was following the music rather than leading it, but it did enable me to look more at the music, spot shapes, learn to cue etc
    Around the same time I was offered the opportunity to dep for a mate in the middle of a wind band in Altrincham whilst he was on holiday. They were very understanding, gave me a lot of help and were probably instrumental in me developing the confidence to actually lead the band in the middle. I also took the number 2 position in a couple of local bands over the next few months which helped.

    My own conducting style has now developed and I can recognise various influences, including the conductor of my old youth band and Dave King (who was in the middle of a couple of the Salford bands) amongst others. I appreciate that conducting is not for everyone but would thoroughly recommend it to any serious player as being a way to properly understand how a band works - the higher up you go, its not just about your own performance, its about mixing with others, and understanding what the MD is looking for. And the best way of understanding anything properly is to actually do the job yourself.

    My own son is now wanting to conduct - at age 11 he's still developing as a player, but I have got the piano scores ready - its Alexa rather than a tape machine now though.......
     
    Jack E, Slider1 and 2nd tenor like this.
  3. 4th Cornet

    4th Cornet Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    312
    What did it mean then?


    This depends on perspective. I've told you mine and you've apparently chosen to ignore it. Other people's responses suggest I'm not alone in this regard.


    The water that apparently keeps you alive is not healthy for this horse so I'm happy to not drink. x
     
    Slider1 and GER like this.
  4. Queeg2000

    Queeg2000 Active Member

    Messages:
    203
    There is a difference between giving someone the chance to try something and forcing them to do it. No one was ever forced into anything, some liked it more than others.

    I don't recall anyone ever complaining that they didn't want to do it, most were just ambivalent about it. Personally I looked forward to it, but as I recall most of the others just went along with it.
     
  5. GER

    GER Active Member

    Messages:
    179
    If my reply made it sound as though people were being forced into doing it, I apologise, it was never my intention. Basically I meant there is a lot of difference between a conductor (a figure of authority, let's not forget that) saying 'right tonight we're all going to have a go at conducting' or 'right tonight anybody who wants a go at conducting is more than welcome to have a go'. I'm sure you will see the difference.
     
    Slider1 and 4th Cornet like this.
  6. GER

    GER Active Member

    Messages:
    179
    Comments like this say more about the author than anyone else. I was enjoying the discussion until you decided to make it personal. I understood the forum to be a place for open discussion, perhaps others don't share that view
     
    Slider1 likes this.
  7. Euphonium Lite

    Euphonium Lite Active Member

    Messages:
    496
    Location:
    Dereham, Norfolk
    It does make me wonder why this forum often descends into personal arguments......

    Is there a shortage of conductors? I dont think there is but there could well become a time in the near future when there could be if the new generation of players dont want to step into the middle

    Should players conduct? In an ideal world everyone would have a go but ultimately for most this is a hobby and no-one should be forced to do something they really dont want to do. I would suggest however that those that dont conduct do miss something from their musical journey, even if its an understanding of how a band actually works or sounds from a different perspective.

    As for me? Sometimes I love standing in the middle, sometimes I hate it. I take every bad contest result personally, whilst good results are due to my players. So there isnt a lot of personal glory in it, certainly in the lower sections, but I do get a buzz from being able to control how the music goes. I know for a fact that if I resigned from my current position chances are I would end up somewhere else.
     
    mikelyons, 2nd tenor and GER like this.
  8. 2nd tenor

    2nd tenor Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    1,329
    Location:
    Chigley
    As I said I’m withdrawing from this thread. However I wouldn’t want you (or anyone else) to take any comment personally and I have tried to speak in general terms that could apply to anyone. So no offence intended and diasspointment on my part that I might have inadvertently given it. Please continue to enjoy the thread, but I’ve come to the conclusion that my words aren’t persuasive enough so I will leave it to others.

    These days the forum is generally a place of open discussion and long may it stay so.
     
  9. David Broad

    David Broad Member

    Messages:
    58
    You have to be a bit careful when encouraging people to do new things musically, or letting them try. I have seen a number of players lose interest when they HAVE been allowed to do what they aspire to but cannot achieve, particularly with solo items. Nerves are the conductors enemy. Heart rate increases, timing goes, everything sounds too slow and it gets worse when things start to go wrong. Brass Band conducting style seems to differ from most in that like many conductors I bring the baton down and where it stops is the first beat. At a recent joint concert I found our local Choir mistress starts the first beat with a flick at the top and the SECOND beat is where the baton stops. Didn't stop the choir following my beat, but I don't think a band could follow her... Mind you I couldn't find a big enough Baton in our local music shop so I made one from a very large knitting needle and a handle cut from a chest expander.
     
  10. Jack E

    Jack E Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    1,093
    Well, this thread seems to have gone way off the original topic - which was most emphatically NOT about whether people should conduct or not, whether people should be encouraged to conduct or not, or whether people should be pushed into conducting or not.

    It was about people who do conduct already, or who would like to - and my puzzlement over why there was so little interest in a conducting workshop. After all, nobody would be the least surprised if a cornet player said they were going to have lessons from a music teacher, or were going to a workshop, so as to improve their playing skills - so why wouldn't people feel the same about wanting to improve their conducting skills?
     
  11. Jack E

    Jack E Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    1,093
    Have you ever been to a conducting workshop, David? I have - the one run by Russell Gray, with my band, and I can assure you that the improvement in the participants was clearly audible.

    MTA - I should point out that, before the workshop, the band were told by our MD that, in order to help the participants, and show them where they were getting it right or wrong, that they should play exactly as each conductor told them to play, even if they felt it was wrong - and leave it to Russell to explain to the participant how he or she should change their conducting to get a better performance from the band.
     
  12. Euphonium Lite

    Euphonium Lite Active Member

    Messages:
    496
    Location:
    Dereham, Norfolk
    To be fair Jack, I would suggest very few long standing MDs would attend - not because they dont think they can improve what they do necessarily, but because beyond establishing a clear beat pattern, it is (I would suggest) more a case of how you relay ideas to a band, rather than being "technically correct". You only have to look at the different styles of conducting between, say Russell Gray, Nick Childs and Richard Evans to realise there is no real "right and wrong". I guess you could teach score reading, but to be honest the key here is preparation and learning the score, regardless of whether its a testpiece or a Bearnarts arrangement - if you know whats coming and what you want it to sound like that is more than half the battle.

    Of more use - personally at least - is to get a different MD in front of the band for a rehearsal especially for a testpiece. Sometimes they will have new ideas that I hadnt thought about, and it makes the band concentrate more because they are dealing with a different face in the middle. However I would suggest there is little to learn about actually "conducting". Also a conducting workshop is not usually with your own band, so what works with the workshop group may not work with your own band, and vice versa.

    I would go as far as saying that a conducting workshop is probably more a positive for someone that wants to try conducting, or is fairly new to doing it and hasnt worked out their own style of doing things yet - but thats only my view
     
    Slider1 likes this.
  13. Jack E

    Jack E Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    1,093
    @Euphonium Lite -
    I don't know what happened in the first part of the conducting workshop, because I wasn't present (that was a classroom job, just for the participants). But when the participants were actually conducting the band, I'd say the lion's share of what they were getting from Russell was exactly what you've described - "how to relay ideas to the band". Bear in mind this is my opinion as an outside observer, so don't take it as gospel - but it appeared to me that what Russell was getting across to them was how to communicate with the band, and what would either help or hinder that communication, so that the band understood the overall interpretation that each conductor was aiming for, and could then play the piece accordingly. And, as I mentioned above, I could really hear the difference between the 'before and after' versions!

    PS - if either Russell or any of the participants would like to add to or correct my impressions, please do so!

    With best regards,

    Jack
     
    Euphonium Lite likes this.
  14. Queeg2000

    Queeg2000 Active Member

    Messages:
    203
    I've seen a few bands do joint concerts with a choir, one that stands out was Cory and Morriston Male Voice Choir.

    With the choir conductor conducting, Cory were all over the place, sounded like a youth band at times, yet the choir were fine, even when Harper was conducting them.

    Even watching from the audience it was clear that both had very different techniques, either worked with the choir, but only one works with a band.

    I've seen this happen every time a collaboration between a choir and a band happens to some degree.
    In essence, choir conductors make poor band conductors.
     
  15. Euphonium Lite

    Euphonium Lite Active Member

    Messages:
    496
    Location:
    Dereham, Norfolk
    Or is it that choirs are less reliant on conductors and use their ears and "group mind" to sing together?
     
  16. 2nd tenor

    2nd tenor Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    1,329
    Location:
    Chigley
    From shared Concerts the impression that I gain is that Choir Conductors don’t beat strick time. To me the gestures of Choir Conductors are more about the relative timing, rhythm and articulation of collective vocal expression in unison than providing a beat upon which the more complex music of Brass Bands is built by individual and indepentantly acting players. When the Band and Choir play together you’re typically OK if the Band is conducted in its normal way ‘cause the Band’s music provides the musical framework which guides and supports what the Choir add (just like when they sing along to a Piano).

    That’s me out of this conversation again now. I’m glad that the thread has moved away from the (contentious) area that it had previously settled on, a comment on a different area shouldn’t upset anyone.
     
    Last edited: Dec 10, 2018
    IoiBP likes this.
  17. Queeg2000

    Queeg2000 Active Member

    Messages:
    203
    My mother sings in a choir, doesn't read music and insists that the higher the conductor raises his hands the higher she has to sing.

    Hardly surprising then that a choir conductor can't conduct a band. The choir conductor seems to actually have very little control over the choir and is actually just there to get them to start together then do a little dance that makes them feel important.
     
    Last edited: Dec 10, 2018
  18. Slider1

    Slider1 Active Member

    Messages:
    251
    Location:
    Kent
    A bit like Harper then:):):)
     
    Euphonium Lite likes this.
  19. Queeg2000

    Queeg2000 Active Member

    Messages:
    203
    Reminded me of a discussion in the band room a while ago that started off why do so many people dislike Cory...

    It went in for a while with some very extreme viewpoints from the pro and anti Cory sides.
     
  20. fsteers

    fsteers Member

    Messages:
    84
    A comment like that makes me suspect that you haven't regularly sung in many choirs, particularly ones in which membership is by audition.

    Choral conducting is at least as much about shaping the vocal inflection to enhance the lyrics as it is shaping the musical line\. That's a skillset unto itself: one which band directors rarely need to develop.

    One of the choirs I sing in is currently being conducted by the former long-time (14 years) Director of Bands at the Univ of North Carolina Chapel Hill, who is filling in while the regular Choir Director is on sabbatical. He's constantly remarking about how much harder choral conducting compared to instrumental conducting, because there's so much more going on musically that band directors don't have to think about. This coming from a guy who routinely conducted symphonic and marching bands of anywhere from 40-150 people.

    In my experience as both a singer and a euphoniumist, choral conductors routinely over-conduct (as compared to normal practice/expectations) when conducting a band, and band directors routinely under-conduct when conducting choirs.
     
    4th Cornet and IoiBP like this.
  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
    Dismiss Notice