Discussion in 'The Rehearsal Room' started by tromwinst, Jun 29, 2010.
Very unimaginative selections
To be fair they have picked a number of new/unused works over the last few years.
That said Carnival Romain is really a concert piece and should stay that way.
Paganini is a great piece, but if it had to be Wilby surely Masquerade would've been a better choice.
Une Vie De Matlot would do me for the 2nd section.....but its not ......An Eric Ball piece I believe oops!!!!
... not sure many 2nd section sop players would agree with you ...
Do you want a massacre in the 2nd section? :tongue:
Oh goody, another Wright triplet-fest. I had enough of that for one year with Leroy Dies in the spring...
(did I mention I don't like Berlioz?)
Actually, just had a listen to it; didn't hear any triple-tonguing at all ... ???
Am I correct in thinking that your post was meant in jest?
We had a blow through of Carnival as well!!! As a Bb bass player ive got to say YUK! and the Eb part has some love NOT bits too!!! All goes at bit of a romp,not much to really enjoy,such a shame!!!
That would of being a good test but played it before at Blackpool many moons ago (1st sec I think)
some fairly big first section numbers in some regions thats probably come into the thought process
We know that you live in Oxford Dave, but have you digested their 'English Dictionary' for breakfast?:wink:
I enjoy your posts but sometimes miss your agenda, (I hope!)
No matter what pieces are announced - or who scribed the original scores, we will always have criticism of the choosing committee - and those that will always 'know better'.
As a supporter of the 'populist' group (those that enjoy a wide range of acknowledged greats, and prefer a piece to be enjoyed for it's recognisable themes, 'tunes' and challenges), I would say that there is an absolute plethora of rarely used classics that would still challenge the best in the land.
We will never please all of the people, all of the time.
(Music historian by any chance?)
Haha... No! Just a keen amateur who likes to pay attention.
Agenda? :lol: I seriously doubt he has one....... he's just really clever. And yes he actually talks like that too (sometimes).
This explains much.....God help us
To my knowledge, David Horsfield isn't, and never has been, on the choosing panel and it's disappointing that, by using the phrase Nice job if you can get it!, you appear to have answered your own question, albeit incorrectly.
It's also disappointing that you have decided to mention David's name in this context at all.
Perhaps when you have the opportunity for another quick glance through the internet archives, you could give us a 'league table' of test piece publishers since 2005.
Surely,they wouldn't select a piece just because it takes 9 minutes to play?
Good point, it never takes that long to decide what level a band is. Contests are lacking the red 'X'. Introduce that, then we can all get to the pub at a reasonable hour......
You would hope not wouldn't you! but in the Midlands and L&SC there are usually large numbers which need considered choices.
RAH finals appears to do it.................................
With so much experience, you would think that they could publish a national test piece without 8 pages of erratta, or is it job done when assigned?
Separate names with a comma.