There is consistent debate on this forum regarding contest results. Bearing this in mind do members think that there should be a minimum standard for those chosen to comment on our performances? If so, what should this be? eg. formal general music qualification, formal adjudication qualification, member of the association of brass band adjudicators, leading brass conductor, first class brass/percussion player, respected musician from other genres, etc. My thought is that they should be selected from the association of brass band adjudicators at the very least. Any comments?