Discussion in 'The Rehearsal Room' started by froggy, Mar 11, 2003.
Just interested to see who's in a marching band (or anyone) and what organisation?
Find more discussions like this one
I used to teach one, flippin eck that was hard work!!
I am not a member of a marching band, but I was wondering if anybody could give me tips on playing marches. I love marches as pieces and can play them OR march, but struggle to do both at the same time. As a Euph player (the biggest instrument not to get a strap) I find this very difficult.
The best piece of advice I have ever been given about marching came from an Army Bandmaster who took my very first band. He always told us not to actually worry about marching, which is essentially just walking in time and provided that you start on the correct foot and keep broadly in line you can then just concentrate on playing. I think that provided you have a reasonable sense of rhythm you should then stay on the correct foot and you can bang out all the notes!
I've often wondered how some people seem capable of Marching at one tempo and playing at another - surely that's really difficult?! It's usually best to just start off with your left foot at the same time as everyone else, then just keep playing - you're feet should keep in time. No promises though :wink:
We do one marching job a year, and it's painful.
Marching is something you have to do a lot of to be good at, you really need to be practicing it regularly.
St. Patrick's Day on Monday - 3.5 hour marching session.. *groan*
My partner plays the Bass Trom and hates marching! He has got a long stride and finds that he easily gets out of step with the rest of the band!
My band doesn't do many marches but one of the worst I have ever done was all down hill. It sound easy but just try it and you'll find that it is just as hard as marching up hill!
I would say that marching downhill is an awful lot harder than marching uphill. When I was in the guards, one of the most awkward jobs we had to do one year was the Tyneside Show. The showground was at the bottom of quite a steep appraoch road, and the sponsors insisted that they wanted the band to appear playing, whereas normally we would have marched down the slope and struck up once we were on the level.
There certainly are skills involved in playing on the march, particularly for brass players, when it is so easy to jar the mouthpiece against your face - much easier when I was playing saxophone, and the mouthpiece was continually between your lips. Someone mentioned previously the problems faced by a player with a long stride, and most bands make the mistake of taking too long strides when on the march. Particularly if there are women in the band, or a number of older players who are less mobile, set a shorter stride, and probably a steadier pace than you might first think, otherwise you can end up looking and feeling like penguins waddling along. If you do have hills to negotiate, you will find most bands tend to speed up when going downhill, so you need to make a conscious effort to keep the pace steady; equally, if marching along not playing there is a tendency to get faster.
Lastly, a lot of bands tend to play everything blastissimo on the march. This is counter-productive, as it is hard on the band as well as wearing for any listeners. Even if heading a march, provided the beat is still played strongly, those following will still be able to keep in step, and the effect for those at the side of the road will be much better. Rest your lips when you get the chance, make the most of the dynamic contrasts, and you will find things a lot easier. For the euphonium player finding the instrument heavy and awkward on the march, I have seen straps used, with a little ingenuity, but I have not found any solution to tired arms when playing bass trombone - it just goes with the territory!
I love marching. Gives me a chance to damage so public ear drums rather than the bands.
yeah were doing st pat's a well
it a long one that
is it in manchester yours?
because that ones on sunday
Nope.. the local Dungarvan one.. on Monday. We get a bank holiday! hurrah!
Have to spend it marching though... boo!
I will watch out for you on the news though.. sometimes we get telemetry from all the ex-pats parades..
Separate names with a comma.